Back to Dashboard
20 photos
$1,395,000
9787 McKinstry Mill Rd, New Windsor
New Windsor · New Windsor
5bd
|
5.0ba
|
3,723sqft
|
73,616lot sqft
|
1.69lot ac
Property Tax
$4,783/yr
Price/Sqft
$375
FEMA ZoneX
Deal Analyst
Get a seasoned buyer's-agent read on this home — strengths, red flags, and the specific offer to make. The candid take most buyers never get, in about 30 seconds.
Want a local agent's take on this home?
Free, no obligation. A local agent will follow up within an hour during business hours.
Location
Description
Extended property details are available from Realtor.
Price History
| Date | Price | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026-07-08 | $1,450,000 | — | Listed |
| 2026-07-09 | $1,450,000 | — | Reduced |
| 2026-09-09 | $1,395,000 | ▼ $55,000 | Current |
Total change: ▼ $55,000 (-3.8%) over 2 updates
Deal Score
This score is personalized — it reflects your importance weights from Preferences. Other users see different scores for the same listing.
51/100
| Price |
|
0 |
| House Size |
|
100 |
| Yard Size |
|
100 |
| Features |
|
40 |
| Flood Risk |
|
100 |
| Year Built |
|
30 |
| Single Story |
|
50 |
| Price/Sqft |
|
5 |
| Days on Market |
|
10 |
| HOA Fee |
|
70 |
| Near Medical |
|
40 |
| Near Grocery |
|
40 |
| Community Pool |
|
20 |
| Property Tax |
|
74 |
| Lot Ratio |
|
100 |
| Price Trend |
|
50 |
| Walkability |
|
40 |
Your Actions
Flags save in your browser only. Create a free account to keep them permanently.
Watch This Area
Get alerts when new listings appear on Mckinstry Mill RD in 21776.
Listing Info
| Source | Realtor |
| First Seen | Jul 08, 2026 |
| Last Updated | Sep 09, 2026 |
| Status | Active |